Is going first too strong? How to find out before your next playtest
First-player advantage hides in plenty of good games. Here is how to measure it, and how to try a fix without losing the game you have.
18 November 2026
Ask a table of playtesters whether going first is an advantage and you will get a shrug. Each of them played two or three games, sat in one seat each time, and remembers the game they won. That is not enough to tell a real edge from a lucky deal.
Yet first-player advantage is one of the most common problems in a new design. The first player gets the first pick of the market, the first shot at the open spaces, the first turn to build towards a bigger turn later. In a short game, one extra turn can be the whole difference.
Why playtests miss it
Suppose the first player wins 55 games in 100 of a two-player game. That is a real edge, worth fixing. But in ten playtest games, the first player will often win five or six, which looks like nothing. Even in thirty games, the numbers bounce around enough to hide it. You need hundreds of games to see a difference that size clearly, and nobody playtests a game hundreds of times.
Let bots play the hundreds of games
Bots do not get tired. On Playtestable, Test with bots plays a few hundred games of your rules and reports on them. The part to read first is Seats compared: how often each seat wins, and whether the difference is bigger than chance would give.
Two things make the answer trustworthy:
- Use bots that think. Random bots are fast and good for finding games that break, but a random player wastes the first turn as easily as the last. Medium or Hard bots, which imagine many ways each move could go, use the first turn the way people do.
- Look at the whole spread, not one number. A seat that wins a little more often is not a problem in a game of five players and a lot of luck. A seat that wins far more often in a two-player game of pure skill is.
Try a fix, side by side
Once you know there is an edge, the classic fixes are simple:
- Give later seats something to start with: an extra coin, an extra card, a point on the score track.
- Let the last player choose first in the next round, or in setup.
- Even out the turns, so every player has the same number before the game ends.
The trouble with trying a fix is that you change the game you have. On Playtestable, a rules option is a "what if?" copy of a few answers, such as "the second player starts with 2 coins". Make one, and Test with bots compares the standard game and the option side by side, under Comparing the rules, with the change marked where it is real. Your standard game stays exactly as it was until you decide.
Then take it to the table
Bots tell you whether the numbers work; people tell you whether the game feels fair. A fix that bots like can still feel fiddly at the table, and an edge that bots find may not bother players who enjoy racing for the first pick. Run your next playtest with the fix in place, and ask the question directly in your playtest form: Did going first, or going last, feel like an advantage?
When the numbers and the players agree, you have your answer.